Start date: 1 October, 2013
- End date: 1 May, 2018
There has been an increasing interest in policy mixes in innovation studies. While it has long been acknowledged that the stimulation of innovation involves different types of policy instruments, how such instruments interact and form policy mixes has only recently become of interest. An area in which policy mixes are particularly important is the field of sustainability transitions. Transitions imply not only the development of disruptive innovations but also of policies aiming for systemic change. Ideally policy mixes for transitions might include elements of ‘creative destruction’, aiding sustainability niches to gain ground while destabilising existing unsustainable regimes.
Further context:
There are two important contexts which have highlighted the need for and have shaped this research project. One is that in policy terms the emergence and diffusion of low-energy innovations is desirable for emission reductions, but this is only one of a variety of policy goals. For example, energy policies are also designed to maintain security of supplies, to keep energy affordable for consumers and industry, and also focus on the economic opportunities afforded by the development of low carbon technologies. These other goals may have synergies with carbon mitigation (e.g. reduced energy demand might lead to increased energy security) but they might also produce important trade-offs (e.g. low energy innovations might be too costly for poor consumers, effectively furthering energy inequality). Recent UK policy and media discussions about rising energy prices, ‘price freezes’ and the government’s review of green taxes on energy bills (which covers for example the costs of the energy company obligation) highlight these tensions. This suggests that the analysis cannot exclusively focus on policies aimed at fostering low-energy innovation but these have to be analysed in a wider energy policy context.
Second, while the issue of policy mixes, which might contain incoherent and inconsistent instruments and goals, has received quite some attention in the policy studies literature for some time (e.g. Howlett and Rayner 2007, Kern and Howlett 2009), there is now also an emerging debate about policy mixes in an innovation studies context (e.g. Flanagan, Uyarra et al. 2011; Borrás and Edquist 2013; Magro and Wilson 2013; Rogge and Reichardt 2013). While it has for long been acknowledged that the stimulation of innovation might involve a number of different types of policy instruments, the issue of how such instruments might interact and form (in)coherent policy mixes has only relatively recently been discovered as being of interest to this community. We argue that an area in which coherent policy mixes are particularly important is the field of sustainability transitions. This literature has received increasing interest in the context of innovation studies but goes beyond mere innovations, examining change at the level of socio-technical systems from the perspective of improvements in environmental sustainability (Markard, Raven et al. 2012). Transitions imply not only the development of innovations but also of policies and policy frameworks aiming for systemic change. In practice, this kind of redesign of policies is challenging, because it presents a contradictory ideology to that of traditional innovation policy focused on economic growth. Innovation policy mixes for transitions might include elements of ‘creative destruction’: aiding sustainability niches to gain ground while simultaneously also stimulating processes inducing the destabilisation of existing unsustainable socio-technical regimes. Therefore, we propose that policy mixes favourable to sustainability transitions need to involve both policies aiming for the ‘creation’ of new and for ‘destroying’ the old. The project will therefore develop a novel conceptualising of policy mixes for low-energy transitions.
Aims and research questions
The aims of this project are:
a) To identify policy goals and instruments which potentially foster or obstruct the emergence and diffusion of low-energy innovations in the areas of mobility, heat, and electricity use;
b) to analyse these existing policy mixes by identifying gaps, complementarities, synergies and trade-offs and explain their development over time;
c) to inform other projects within the Centre and synthesise policy-relevant insights across Centre projects and research themes.
The research questions are:
- To what extent to current UK energy policy goals and instruments add up to a coherent policy mix suitable for fostering transitions towards low energy systems?
- How can the emergence and change of policy mixes over time be explained?
- What impact does the current policy mix have on target groups?
- Are there ways in which synergies can be improved and trade-offs be avoided within such policy mixes?
Project Documents
Policy synergies and trade-offs project outline (956 KB - pdf)
Presentation at the Department of Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy on German Energy Policy, 31 January 2017
Karoline Rogge gave a talk at the Department of Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) on German energy policy and about how Germany is making the transition to a low carbon energy system, commonly referred to as Energiewende. She was invited to speak as part of the International Network Seminar series, an internal seminar series at BEIS.
Browse her slides for more information.
Dialogue session at SPRU 50th Anniversary Conference, 7 September 2016
Karoline Rogge and Florian Kern organised a dialogue session on ‘Policy mixes for innovation: Progress and challenges ahead‘.The session featured experts from the OECD and the EU and was well attended by academic and non-academic participants alike.
Keynote presentation at OECD workshop, Seoul, 7 July 2016
Florian Kern was invited to give a keynote presentation at an OECD workshop on technology development and demonstration for transformative change in Seoul, 7
th of July 2016.The presentation titled ‘
From technology demonstration to transition experiments‘ drew on research done at CIED.
Presentation at ESRC-DECC knowledge exchange workshop, 17 May 2016
Florian Kern was invited to give a presentation at a knowledge exchange workshop hosted by DECC on ‘
The UK renewable energy transition – lessons from history and experiences abroad‘.
Home energy efficiency is a 'win-win' says UK Energy and Climate Change Select Committee report, which uses CIED research as evidence
Research by the
Centre on Innovation and Energy Demand has helped to inform the recently published
UK Energy and Climate Change Select Committee (ECCC) report on Home Energy Efficiency. CIED originally responded to the ECCC call in 2015 for scrutiny priorities, listing Home Energy Efficiency as a key focus area. The centre later responded to the official inquiry on the subject, and in December 2015 CIED
Senior Research Fellow Jan Rosenow, was called on to
give evidence to the Committee. Jan’s oral evidence, and CIED written evidence is widely cited in the final report.
The ECCC report reveals that the frequent changes to government energy policies are denting consumer confidence in the sector and hampering the UK’s ability to improve energy efficiency. It calls on the government to make improving energy efficiency in new and existing homes a “top priority” and to identify ways to help poor households struggling to pay their fuel bills. Read more.
Invited seminar at UNU-MERIT/School of Governance seminar, Maastricht University
Dr Florian Kern gave an
invited presentation at UNU-MERIT/School of Governance in Maastricht, the Netherlands on his joint paper with CIED colleague
Dr Paula Kivimaa on ‘
Creative destruction or mere niche support? Innovation policy mixes for sustainability transitions’ which was recently published in the journal
Research Policy.
UNU-MERIT is the United Nations University – Maastricht Economic and Social Research Institute on Innovation and Technology, one of Europe’s key centres of innovation research so it was a special honour to be invited to give a seminar there. The presentation first introduced the Centre on Innovation and Energy Demand, its research agenda and then highlighted key findings regarding the need for innovation policy to go beyond just focusing on creating alternative niches for low energy innovations. The presentation stimulated an interesting discussions with many questions about how to study policy mixes and whether the technological innovation systems approach is appropriate, the political difficulties of phasing out industries, whether the framework could also be applied in a developing country context, etc.
The presentation slides can be accessed here [PDF 862KB]. The paper is available open access here.
Workshop presentation on 'Encouraging Energy Efficiency in Buildings'.
In October 2015, Dr Jan Rosenow will participate in a joint workshop between UCL ISR and the Grantham Research Institute on ‘Encouraging Energy Efficiency in Buildings’.
Keynote speaker at ResPublica Energy Efficiency Private Roundtable
In July 2015, Dr Jan Rosenow was a keynote speaker on ‘Paving the way for domestic energy efficiency in the UK’ at the ResPublica Energy Efficiency Private Roundtable, Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, in London.
Keynote speaker at European Commission Workshop
In June 2015, Dr Jan Rosenow was a a keynote speakers at the ‘Compliance with EED Article 7 Requirements Concerning Methodologies for Energy Savings Calculation – Overview of Member States’ Notifications. The workshop was organised by the Joint Research Centre of the European Commission: Calculation Methods for Energy Savings under Article 7 of the Energy Efficiency Directive, in Brussels.
Response to Ofgem’s consultation paper on non-traditional business models in the electricity sector
Dr Florian Kern and Dr Mari Martiskainen provided evidence to Ofgem’s discussion paper on ‘
Non-traditional business models: Supporting transformative change in the energy market.’
CIED ‘travelling seminar series’ visits Green Alliance
On February 26
th, as part of CIED’s ‘travelling seminar series’ connecting it’s research to key stakeholder organisations, Dr Florian Kern and Centre Manager Sarah Schepers visited
Green Alliance, a charity and independent think tank focused on ambitious leadership for the environment. The organisation is a member of the Centre on Innovation and Energy Demand’s Advisory Group playing a very valuable role advising on the policy relevance of the Centre’s research. Florian gave a seminar on ‘Policy mixes and the transition towards a low carbon economy’ where he outlined some of the conceptual thinking around sustainability transitions and policy mixes, often including various policy goals, instruments and strategies. It has long been acknowledged within ‘innovation studies’ that the stimulation of innovation involves different types of policy instruments, but how such instruments interact and form policy mixes has only recently become of interest. He argued that transitions imply not only the development of disruptive innovations but also of policies aiming for systemic change. Ideally policy mixes for transitions might include elements of ‘
creative destruction’, aiding low energy innovations to gain ground while destabilising existing, unsustainable, socio-technical energy systems. He then went on to apply this thinking to current UK policies to stimulate energy efficiency in buildings. This was followed by a very interesting discussion with the Green Alliance team about the applicability of this research to current energy policymaking , making some interesting observations on the research project which will help in later stages of the work.